Friday, August 12, 2011

book review: The Help by Kathryn Stockett

The Help (Movie Tie-In)The backstory: The Help was longlisted for the 2010 Orange Prize. It's also now a movie.

My thoughts: Oh, The Help. I wanted to like you so much. Bloggers I almost always agree with all loved it. As most of the reading public is familiar with The Help and has probably read it, this review will be frank about the novel and may include spoilers for people who somehow have never heard of it.

I fully admit it: I'm not normally a fan of Southern fiction. Despite living in Atlanta for thirteen years, I never developed a love for Southern fiction or culture. Southern food, however, I fully embraced.

I picked up The Help once before a few years ago and only made it a few pages because of the Southern speak. This time I persevered, but I found it all rather dull. I did really like the character of Skeeter. I'm often drawn to idealistic young female characters who dream of being a writer, so that comes as no surprise. Still, I found nothing in Skeeter's story surprising, so it wasn't enough to carry this novel for me.

My biggest problem with The Help was its pacing. I think there's a heart of a good story in there, but the plot seemed incredibly obvious to me, and Stockett's writing wasn't strong enough to make me enjoy the journey that seemed clear from the the time we meet Skeeter. Would my outlook be different if I read The Help too years ago before its contents became so well known? Perhaps. For being 454 pages long, very little actually happens. I wanted more conflict, intrigue and sadness. I found it disconcertingly gentle. Compared with the fantastic Scottsboro by Ellen Feldman (my review), The Help seemed so watered down.

I also really disliked the faux-Southern voices of Minny and Aibileen. I found it awkward and distracting to see 'a' used in place of 'of.' I was annoyed that the the writing didn't reflect clipped g's and other hallmarks of Southern dialect. It seemed an odd compromise, and it distracted from Aibileen and Minny's narratives.

There were things I liked. I found the portrayal of Aibileen's church to be very positive and inspiring. The congregation provided the only emotional connection I had to the story.

Despite my misgivings with the novel as a whole, I am looking forward to the film. With 454 pages of a novel to fit into a film, I think the pacing issues will be solved. Although I found Stockett's writing underwhelming, the cast of the film is superb, and I believe their acting could carry this story to the top.

Favorite passage: It's a bad sign when there is not one memorable passage in 454 pages.

The verdict: I wasn't a fan of The Help, but I am looking forward to seeing the movie.

Rating: 3 stars (out of 5)
Length: 464 pages
Publication date: February 10, 2009
Source: I bought it (in hardcover) before I got my Kindle a year and a half ago)

As an affiliate, I receive a very, very small commission when you make a purchase through any of the above links. Thank you for helping to support my book habits that bring more content to this blog!

7 comments:

  1. I am sorry to hear you didn't love this one! I saw the movie last night and thought it was phenomenal. I think there's a good chance you'll like it despite not being a fan of the book.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is one of the reasons that I have held back on reading this book, despite the fact that I own it in hardcover. I just think the hype is going to be something that ruins it for me, and I don't want to be the only one in existence that doesn't love this one. That's why your review was refreshing to me. At least now I know if it doesn't work for me that I am not alone!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I enjoyed reading this book, but I find myself agreeing with all your criticisms. It is predictable and light, but for some reason this didn't bother me. I was swept up in the setting and willing the predictable to happen. I'm looking forward to watching the film and I hope that you enjoy it too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm sorry you didn't like this one. I sometimes think that a book can't live up to all of the hype but like you said, it may also just not be the book for you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lek wywo³uje [url=http://www.perfumeria.rel.pl]Perfumeria internetowa[/url] obni¿enie asymilowania podwaliny tluszczowych dziêki cz³owieczy twór. Owo w ka¿dym calu dziewiczy specyfik dla dam, które potrzebuj¹ odchudziæ siê natomiast pokonaæ na zdrowszy pr¹d posi³ków. Lekarstwo ów akceptuje wzmóc efektywnoœæ odchudzania o 45 % w zestwieniu z przeznaczeniem [url=http://www.hotelmorskieoko.pl/uroda-i-zdrowie/perfumy/perfumeria-internetowa.html]Perfumeria[/url] jeno diety i æwiczeñ fizycznych. Panaceum tamten zdobêdziesz w aptece internetowej. Inwitujemy do energicznej online taniej apteki internetowej po wyci¹gi oraz po dane o œrodkach. Fur w zwi¹zku z tym alli Zachwalamy sami dobr¹ zap³atê medykamentów oraz œciœle mówi¹c posiad³oœci¹ satysfakcjê zwiedzaj¹cych paginê. Apteka internetowa jest jedn¹ z siedmiu najbardziej wyj¹tkowych natomiast odró¿niaj¹cych siê portali zapewniaj¹cych zaopatrywanie uzysków farmacetycznych.Musimy przedstawiæ w tym momencie trójka typy prepratów. Nasza apteka o jakiej zapisujemy dzia³a w procedura pewny zaœ porucza [url=http://www.perfumeria.tm.pl]Perfumeria[/url] koncentraty w ci¹gu ledwo jednego dnia odk¹d momentu uskutecznienia twojego zainteresowania. Tylko z tego do³¹cza zjawiskowe [url=http://www.artykulandia.pl/Perfumeria-internetowa-a10.html]Perfumeria internetowa[/url] oceny pacjentów. Na wiotki brzuszekJest moc za³¹czników diety na wyszczuplenie. Do g³êbokich nale¿¹ te zawieraj¹ce w sk³adzie l-karnitynê, to¿ rzeczwiœcie sprawdzonym tudzie¿ i udowodnionym postêpowaniem byæ mo¿e zaakceptowaæ siê jeno alli posiadaj¹cy tzw.orlistat.Sposób od¿ywiania siê choæ i æwiczenie fizyczne w znacz¹cym stopniu rozstrzygaj¹ o dobrym spêdzeniu [url=http://www.hotelmorskieoko.pl/uroda-i-zdrowie/perfumy/perfumeria.html]Perfumeria[/url] donios³oœci.Na menopauzêMenopauza jest nieraz, jak krwawienie ustaje, i jajniki ca³kowicie ustaj¹ wyzwalaæ jajeczka. Na menopazuê dynamiczne s¹ takie preparaty kiedy diohespan max, diosminex obejmuj¹ce diosminê. Okres menopauzy chocia¿ nie znamionuje gwoli facjaty pieknej katastrofy zaœ wypada spoœród ni¹ siê zmierzyæ.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I actually found this book to be perfect for an audiobook production, which is how I first experienced it. I would highly recommend you give that medium a try - there are three narrators voicing each of the characters, and the one who voices Minny is also the same actress in the film. Quite frankly, I think it would have been tough to read this book on the printed page, but I think it's a perfect choice for audio, and particularly for those who would like to try to listen to audiobooks. Even my husband liked it! :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with Natalie that the audio version was better than the book alone. The movie may be better than the book, too, but I don't plan on going to see it.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to comment. Happy reading!