Posts

Showing posts with the label A People's read-a-long

A People's Read-a-long: Week 17

Image
Welcome to Week 17 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and as someone who would rather read fiction, I'm still finding the pace a delightful way to sprinkle in some non-fiction.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week. This week is  a week everyone is posting.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check them all out here .) My thoughts:  Chapter 17, "Or Does It Explode?" focuses on the civil rights movement. Zinn opens the chapter by backtracking in time to the early 1900s and tracing the artistic output of black people: "a society of complex controls, both crude and refined, secret thoughts can often be found in the arts, and so it was in black society." It was a delight to read the beautiful words of so many black poets and writers and ponder the distinctions between jazz and blues music as political messages. After reading Half Blood Blues...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 16

Image
Welcome to Week 16 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and as someone who would rather read fiction, I'm still finding the pace a delightful way to sprinkle in some non-fiction.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week. This week is not  a week everyone is posting.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check them all out here .) My thoughts:  Chapter 16, "A People's War?," focuses on World War II.  In this chapter Zinn addresses the notion that WWII was a people's war. Wars have been prominent in other chapters of this book, so it was interesting to explore if World War II was different. Were the people as united for the war privately as they were publicly? I'm typically somewhat cynical, particularly when it comes to politics, and I initially  thought some of Zinn's cynicism was oversimplification: "Roosevelt was as much concer...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 15

Image
Welcome to Week 15 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and I'm finding the pace deligtful.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week. This week is  a week everyone is posting.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check them all out here .) My thoughts:  Chapter 15, "Self-Help in Hard Times," continues the theme of economic inequality through the Great Depression. In many ways, this chapter feels the culmination of much of this book. One of the things I enjoyed most in this chapter were the excerpts from writers at the time who were trying to draw attention to the issues. Zinn included excerpts from F. Scott Fitzgerald, John Steinbeck, Langston Hughes and Sinclair Lewis. There were far more moments of astonishment at the downright ignorance, or intentional lies, coming from the leaders: "Herbert Hoover had said, not long before the crash: ...

A People's Read-a-long: Weeks 12, 13, & 14

Image
Welcome to Week 14 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and I'm finding the pace deligtful.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week. This week is not  a week everyone is posting.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four ,  five ,  six ,  seven ,  eight and nine ,  ten , and eleven .) After getting off track, I'm caught up and will now return to my weekly Monday posts (I hope). My thoughts:  Chapter 12, entitled "The Empire and the People," brings us into the 20th century, where my knowledge of history is much stronger. This chapter, however, focuses on the Spanish-American War and the Philippine-American War, which I realized I knew very little about. The themes of war as a unifying force is once again apparent. The focus is really on the growing internatio...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 11

Image
Welcome to Week 11 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and I'm finding the pace deligtful.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week. This week is a week everyone is posting.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four ,  five ,  six ,  seven ,  eight and nine , and ten .) My thoughts:  Chapter 11, entitled "Robber Barons and Rebels," focuses on industrialization, the corresponding shifts in populations, and the rise of workers rights. On a personal note, there is something guilt-inducing about reading about the rise of the workers rights movement while on a blissful nine-day paid staycation. Here are my favorite tidbits and trivia from this (long) chapter: I'm oddly fascinated by population shifts: "Between 1860 and 1914, New York grew from 850,000 to...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 10

Image
Welcome to Week 10 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and I'm finding the pace deligtful.  Note: the hosts have switched to posting every other week instead of every week, but I'm bucking the trend and posting every week.  (Missed the earlier posts? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four ,  five ,  six ,  seven , and eight and nine .) My thoughts:  Chapter 10, entitled "The Other Civil War," focuses on the rights of renters and property owners. It opens with the Anti-Renter movement that sprung up in the Hudson Valley over the rampant wealth of landowners, who often had a legal right to the timber and other resources on the land. The scope of their control was massive: "The tenants paid taxes and rents. The largest manor was owned by the Rensselaer family, which ruled over about eighty thousand tenants and had accumulated a fortune of $41 million." The anti-rent movement grew quickly a...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 9

Image
Welcome to Week 9 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and I'm finding the pace deligtful. Note: we've switched to posting every other week instead of every week.  (Missed the first seven posts? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four ,  five ,  six  and seven .) My thoughts:  Chapter 8, entitled "We Take Nothing by Conquest, Thank God," focuses on expansionism, a trend in recent chapters, with an emphasis on the Mexican-American War. As a reader, I must say, I'm losing a sense of time in this book. It's not told in a strictly linear manner, and the themes are often the same in the book as a whole. I'm embarrassed to say knowing Polk is the President does not clue me in to which year it is. I do appreciate, however, when Zinn emphasizes the shifting demographics rather than years: "Whereas in 1830, 1 percent of the population of the United States was foreign-born, by the Mexican war the numb...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 7

Image
Welcome to Week 7 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and the pace is perfect. (Missed the first six weeks? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four ,  five , and six .) My thoughts:  Chapter 7, entitled "As Long as Grass Grows or Water Runs," focuses on the removal of Native Americans from land east of the Mississippi River. This chapter was depressing, which is becoming a theme. Again, I felt somewhat familiar with the material. As someone who grew up in Kansas, I was surrounded by geography named for Native Americans and attended schools named Tecumseh and Pawnee. Still, some of the more gruesome details were new to me. What, or rather who, struck me most during this chapter was Andrew Jackson. Until this point, even as the rich white settlers took over, there have been elements of humanity. I had trouble seeing anything good or human in Jackson. I also only highlighted three passages in this chapter...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 6

Image
Welcome to Week 6 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and the pace is perfect. (Missed the first five weeks? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three ,  four , and five .) My thoughts:  Chapter 6, entitled "The Intimately Oppressed," focuses on women's roles and the beginnings of the women's rights movement. I majored in women's studies in college, and I already adore many of the key players in this chapter. What I found most interesting in this chapter was how Zinn placed the early women's movement within context of the rest of the book: "Putting all women into the same category—giving them all the same domestic sphere to cultivate—created a classification (by sex) which blurred the lines of class, as Nancy Cott points out." It's a fascinating concept, and one I had not thought of earlier, even though it sounds quite obvious in retrospect. In this sense, it becomes much more difficult to treat wo...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 5

Image
Welcome to Week 5 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and the pace is perfect. (Missed the first four weeks? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two ,  three , and four .) My thoughts:  Chapter 5, entitled "A Kind of Revolution," addresses the distracting impact of war on the lower and middle classes and the Constitution. This chapter is filled with cynicism and provides haunting parallels to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as the current state of Congressional elections. Here are some snapshots of (correct, in my opinion) cynicism: "Ruling elites seem to have learned through the generations—consciously or not—that war makes them more secure against internal trouble." "In short, as Francis Jennings puts it, the white Americans were fighting against British imperial control in the East, and for their own imperialism in the West." Under the illusion of the mandate that all must serve in the Revolution...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 4

Image
Welcome to Week 4 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and the pace is perfect. (Missed the first three weeks? Check out my posts for weeks  one ,  two , and three .) My thoughts:  Chapter 4, entitled "Tyranny Is Tyranny," feels like a watershed chapter. Its focus is on the Declaration of Independence and its wording.The opening line of the chapter sets the stage perfectly: "Around 1776, certain important people in the English colonies made a discovery that would prove enormously useful for the next two hundred years. They found that by creating a nation, a symbol, a legal unity called the United States, they could take over land, profits, and political power from favorites of the British Empire." What I found most interesting in this chapter was the discussion of the rights that come from owning property, and, in particular, voting. It's a clear extension of the class system. I found myself thinking of how this country woul...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 3

Image
Welcome to Week 3 of  A People's Read-a-long ! We're reading a chapter a week, and the pace is perfect. (Missed the first two weeks? Check out my posts for weeks one and two .) I'm still thoroughly enjoying this read-a-long. This week I even took Jill's advice and snagged a copy of Voices of a People's History of the United States , which is collection of primary source documents organized around the chapters of A People's History of the United States.  I'm not reading all of them, but I'm dipping into the ones that most interest me. It's adding another fascinating layer to this book. My thoughts:  Chapter 3, entitled "Persons of Mean and Vile Condition," deals with the class system in the colonies. More specifically, Zinn addresses how class was impacted by the existing class system of Britain and how it shifted to include Indians, slaves, (white) servants, and former servants. I'm deeply concerned at what I see as our current cla...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 2

Image
Welcome to Week 2 of  A People's Read-a-long ! I'm still thoroughly enjoying this read-a-long. It's incredibly easy to keep track of reading one chapter a week. I even managed to keep up while being away at ALA Midwinter most of this week (I'm coming home tonight...hooray for  plane reading time!) My thoughts:  Chapter 2, entitled "Drawing the Color Line," focuses on slavery and its origins in the United States. I found this topic illuminating, depressing and simultaneously fascinating and difficult to read. Having read and enjoyed Property , Valerie Martin's Orange Prize -winning novel of slavery earlier this month ( my review ), I found myself connecting the dots between Zinn's history and the story of Manon in 1828 Louisiana. What I found most interesting in this chapter was the role of racism. When I think of slavery, I think of racism, but Zinn outlined this distinction: "In the early years of slavery, especially, before racism as a wa...

A People's Read-a-long: Week 1

Image
Welcome to Week 1 of A People's Read-a-long ! So far I'm thoroughly enjoying this read-a-long. It's incredibly easy to keep track of reading one chapter a week. I may not post every week, but I wanted to share my initial thoughts and a couple of my favorite passages from Chapter 1 this week. My thoughts: It's rare to find a non-fiction book without an introduction, and consequently, chapter 1 read like a combination of an introduction and a first chapter. Zinn provided context for his view of understanding history as he told the story of the first chapter: Columbus, the Indians and Human Progress. I appreciate Zinn's view of reading and understanding history as a modern person: "My point is not that we must, in telling history, accuse, judge, condemn Columbus in absentia. It is too late for that; it would be a useless scholarly exercise in morality." I'm fascinated by how different societies, past and present, viewed gender. In chapter 1, I learn...

A People's Read-a-long

Image
Jill at Fizzy Thoughts and Jenners at Life...with Books are hosting A People's Read-a-long for Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States . I've been meaning to read this book since 1997, when I saw Good Will Hunting . Instead of reading the book, however, I proceeded to see the film six times in the theater and many, many more times once it came out on video (and then dvd.) It's one of my all-time favorite films. Mr. Nomadreader and I own both a print copy and a Kindle copy, and we're both going to participate! The read-a-long is my kind of sensible one: it starts Monday, January 16th, the federal holiday for Martin Luther King, Jr. Chapter 1 is due that Monday. Each Monday thereafter, a chapter is due. The read-a-long will finish Monday, July 9th with the 25th chapter. I swore off read-a-longs last year when I failed at Anna Karenina , but I think non-fiction will work better for me. I like to read at my own pace with fiction, but I'm ...