- The Round House by Louise Erdrich
- This is How You Lose Her by Junot Diaz
- A Hologram for the King by Dave Eggers
- Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk by Ben Fountain (4 stars)
- The Yellow Birds by Kevin Powers (4.5 stars)
- A Partial History of Lost Causes by Jennifer duBois
- The Book of Life by Stuart Nadler
- Vaclev & Lena by Haley Tanner
- We the Animals by Justin Torres
- Battleborn by Claire Vaye Watkins
- Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward (4 stars)
- The Sojourn by Andrew Krivak (4 stars)
- The Tiger's Wife by Tea Obreht (3.5 stars)
- The Buddha in the Attic by Julie Otsuka (4.5 stars)
- Binocular Vision: New & Selected Stories by Edith Pearlman (4 stars)
- The People of Forever Are Not Afraid by Shani Boianjiu (coming 2013)
- Before You Suffocate Your Own Fool Self by Danielle Evans
- The Walking People by Mary Beth Keane
- Bear Down, Bear North: Alaska Stories by Melinda Moustakis
- Where Things Come Back by John Corey Whaley
2010 Fiction Winner
- Lord of Misrule by Jaimy Gordon
- Parrot and Olivier in America by Peter Carey
- Great House by Nicole Krauss
- So Much for That by Lionel Shriver
- I Hotel by Karen Tei Yamashita
- The Sweet Relief of Missing Children by Sarah Braunstein
- The Orange Eats Creeps by Grace Krilanovich
- The Tiger's Wife by Tea Obrecht
- How to Escape from a Leper's Colony by Tiphanie Yanique
- Once the Shore by Paul Yoon
- Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann
- American Salvage by Bonnie Jo Campbell
- In Other Rooms, Other Wonders by Daniyal Mueenuddin
- Lark & Termite by Jayne Anne Phillips
- Far North by Marcel Theroux